For hogs, the FMJ _might_ penetrate far enough, most of the time, but I would not want to count on it stopping a hog up close. and .44 Mag., Elmer Keith deserves inclusion into that group. The .357 Magnum is a sound and useful design, one that will continue to be enjoyed by shooters and hunters alike for decades to come. Two seperate shops have recomended a 45 Colt over a 357 Mag to me for a hunting/shooting gun. https://www.patreon.com/user?u=5769301 I do know the 357 with the right loads in plenty ample for the above game out to 70 yards. I'd like to have it leave the muzzle before the boar decides I'm within "snack" range. I use H-110 powder for all my deer hunting loads, shoot HP-38, and titegroup for my lighter loads for playing around. I don't own a .44 mag, though. ammo I would trust to bust a big hog would have to be loaded with a wide flat nose hard cast heat treated bullet. The 44 Mag’s wider case accordingly seats a broader and heavier bullet – two factors that … 90% of my hand loads are hard cast of lead, tin and wheel weights, 250 grain Keith bullets in .44 special cases at 1,200 fps (Elmer Keith’s load). 158 gr cast bullets are about the same story in the 357 Mag. If your hunting lets say 50 yards, 44 mag out of a rifle (gains more FPS) is devastating to thin skinned game like whitetail deer. vs. .44 Mag. With the 44 mag it's all about knowing your limits. Getting 1400 to 1500fps out of ether cartridge is not hard to do with a 7.5" barrel . (I know, a .357 mag with a long barrel is capable of taking larger game and has been doing so for over 75 years.) The .44 will perform much more effectively than any .357 load. .41 mag vs. .44 mag I'm looking to purchase a new handgun to carry with me while I'm out bow hunting in bear country. You might need the .44 if you want to take larger game, but I think the range would be about the same. The 44 Mag’s case is nearly the same length as the 357 Mag’s, but its greater diameter gives it approximately 45 percent more capacity for propellant. Clay Cooper ... A .357 is marginal at best and you would be better suited with a .44 magnum and a hard cast load while shooting from a tree stand. .357 S&W Magnum While some folks claim the .44 Magnum is the minimum for charging bears, many others have opted for a Glock 20 in 10mm Auto and, interestingly enough, passed right by the .357 S&W Magnum. It is true the .44 Remington Magnum produces more energy than the .41 if standard factory loads are compared (800 ft-lbs. vs. 700 ft-lbs.). I plan on using this solely for whitetail/ coyote hunting. If your going to use a 357 Mag on Hogs, do not use Hollow Points, use a good solid Soft point for deeper penetration Comment. I even shot a 800 pound red stag with the 45 colt load and 1 shot at 75 yards did the job. The same article has the .357 mag at about 630 ft. lbs.. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketing type. The 10mm is a newcomer in the hunting world, but has become a big player in the market for bear hunters or anyone needing extra power. The 44 mag rifle is a whole different critter. Any place that sells ammo, even in this current ammo scare, will typically have 44 mag. Shot several deer with the 444 marlin, bullets performs great. S&W 686. My concern with the .44 mag is the second shot; I am able to reacquire the target far faster with a .357 or a .41 mag, than with a .44 magnum. This is the link to Paul's patreon account. I would like to hear opinions from actual users of … Just bought some at Wally, this morning, in fact. The .44 mag in a rifle preforms much better than in a handgun, you get a tad more velocity and energy in the longer barrel of a rifle with that round and because of that it works very well for black bear if you place the shot just right. Not sure how big your deer are, but it ought to be as good on them if they are under the 200-250 pound range. rifle round delivering twice that at about 2000. Just about any place that sells ammo, then, will have 44 mag. This load has never failed me on a hunt. Whitetail hunters have a wide variety of factory .44 Mag. 8. Earlier posters have astutely commented that a second shot with a wild boar may be urgently required. I'm looking at the .41 mag vs. the .44 mag and looking for some pros and cons from all that would like to contribute. I do own a .45 Colt (blackhawk) and a .30-30 handgun (Contender) for handgunning bigger game. I know 44 mag is more powerful and I was thinkin of the super redhawk with the 7.5in barrel for 44 mag against the 6in gp100. The 45/70 will also do the job quite well. offers even more versatility when handloaded. In my youth I read an article in a magazine about testing the killing power of the 44 mag on a very large pig. ammo at their disposal. There have been many visionaries in the firearms industry—the John Brownings and the Peter Paul Mausers—but we firmly believe that if for nothing other than the .357 Mag. rifle - 6.5 ft. lbs..44 Mag., 240 at 1760 fps, 6.5 lb. If you want to try a .357 mag, download your .44 mag brass with 180 or 200 gr bullets at 1200 to 1300 fps. 10mm generally packs higher muzzle energies thanks in large part to the larger bullets. While I've taken hogs with .357 and deer fold quickly with it, I have to go with .44 on hogs particularly as a caliber. If you don’t intend to roll your own, no worries, the prevalent array of factory ammunition has got you covered. Firing a .44 Magnum without having experienced the recoil of a .357 Magnum may result in injury. An advantage of the 357 Mag, is it's easily found in repeating pistols besides lever guns. The only 357 Mag. The other truth is the terminal effect on either an animal or human doesn’t change much between those two numbers. of muzzle energy, with the .30-30 Win. I know a person who has used a 357 mag rifle at close range for deer. I do load up some 300gr XTP Mag loads for hogs also. My own handloads move a 185gr FN from Beartooth Bullets at 1250fps from my 4" bbl. has all the power you would need, but I distrust the small bullet's capability in the heavily muscled hog. No such thing as "overkill" and a big hog can take some killing. This comes with the disclaimer that my only hunting opportunities involve hogs and deer at ranges of less than about 150 yards. 10% of my .44 loads are in .44 mag cases. The 44 seemed to do the job but as they were walking over to inspect the kill, the pig awoke and charged. I like handloading practice pistol ammo for my four grandchildren and myself in .38 Spl and .357 Mag. If you are going to limit yourself to factory loads, the 44 mag is much more practical. In mark3smle test you can see the .357 penetration at 22 inches. On paper the .357 mag. At least be near a tree you can climb darn fast! .357 Mag., 158 at 1830 fps, 6.0 lb. Hi--I'm very new to shooting and reloading--at this point I hold the franchise on ignorance. Edit to my last post: My memory is apparently faulty, Wikipedia has the .44 Mag handgun round delivering about 1000 ft. lbs. A Glock 20 is going to weigh less than any .44 mag except the Scadnium S+W's. I handload my Ruger redhawk 44,in a 7 1/2 bbl; Handi rifle in 444 and 44 mag, all with 240gr, XTP. You will discover that .357 mag level loads are excellent for coyotes, pronghorn under 75 yd, and small deer out to 60 yd. 170 gr cast pullets can be driven to about the same velocity as a copper bullet in the 30-30. The BTB 185 has a flat or meplat the same size as a .44 Keith SWC for maximum damage and penetration. See attached picture of shot placement. I'm not sure I'll be able to use cast boolits because whatever gun I get I want a near max load for hunting. Most any expandable bullet will tackle deer and I tend to lean toward the 240-grainers. Perfect choice! I put a … how much more powerful is a hot 44 mag load vs … Post Cancel. The rifleman killed it. My favorite load for hunting with the .44 mag is a 240gr hard cast semi-wadcutter over 20.0grs. .41 Mag. A … 10mm vs. 357 Mag Muzzle Energy. Even with similar bullets, however, it appears the 10mm does slightly better. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .357 Magnum vs .40 S&W ammo rounds. I've seen some pretty large hogs dropped in their tracks with heavy .357 loads. I was interested in a 357 because of less recoil and cheaper ammo. Traditionally, the .357 magnum has a long track record of a mini-hand cannon for personal defense. It is important to educate yourself on the varying recoil effects of a .357 Magnum and a .44 Magnum prior to using them. The .357 Magnum is a powerful cartridge, but in this case it takes a narrow 2nd place to the 10mm Auto. I use it in my 10 5/8" mod-29, my super blackhawk and my T/C Contender. I would not use a jacketed soft point or hollow point on boar due to their thick and tough shoulders. Several folks … They had a rifleman aiming at the pig also. The first shop seemed to dislike 357 period, so I didn't give it much thought. The .44 Mag. The .357 Magnum in the neat Marlin 1884C carbine is the least powerful of our comparison cartridges and also kicks the least, by a wide margin. Upon inspection, the 44 mag hit the pig's skull and splattered. I never had a problem with my Marlin .44 carbine feeding reliably. Most are best suited to whitetail deer hunting, although, with proper placement, can be used on big game such as black bear, elk or wild hogs. Hogs are still heavy 357 game . Ok, before I start I know the 357 vs. 44 mag has been debated to death. rifle - 13.1 ft. lbs. I have taken 2 hogs with 340 rain buffalo bore 44 mag and 6 with buffalo bore 45 colt plus p 330 grain load every on had complete penetration and quick death. 10mm will drop a boar, but the .44 mag will still be more powerfull and shoot heavier bullets. Hogs have a well deserved rep for … of 2400. I'd say a good, heavy .44 magnum semi-wadcutter will handle any hog you run into. The following .44 Mag ammo is at the top when choosing rounds for hunting. I'd go with a .44 mag., minimum 240 bullet, a .265 or 300 grain would be even better. This is a point worth remembering when shopping for a young shooter's first centerfire rifle. You can can find full power 44 mag loads, even at Wal-mart. .44 mag, 6 inch barrel, blued S&W. It really depends if you want a revolver or a semi auto, and how much weight you wnat to carry. I'm thinking how convenient a .357 mag lever rifle would be if it is powerful enough for hogs at under 200 yards (most likely under 75 yds). An easy check is to consult a good reloading book. I am asking this question as I want to pick up a new Ruger Super Blackhawk in either on of the calibers. Magnum legends: .300 Win Mag vs. 7mm Rem Mag The .300 Winchester Magnum (Win Mag) has reigned supreme for nearly 60 years and is one of America’s most prolific cartridges. .44 Mag is not interchangeable with .44 Spl (.44 Spl can be fired in a .44 Mag, however) Best .44 Mag Ammo for Hunting. I have used a 240gr nosler sp bulle for some years in my 44 and works well of deer and never recovered one . As such, the following is for comparative … Max pressure is about the same.
Modway Veer Mesh Office Chair, Lee Deluxe Carbide 4-die Set 45 Acp, Blox Fruits Script Vermillion, Yamaha Aircraft Engines, Hpi Savage Discontinued, Assassin's Creed Valhalla Patch Reddit, Hk416 Build Tarkov,